Parallel Session 3

Thursday 3rd September, 15:50-16:50

Room A - 20-minute Presentations

"The Degree is Almost a Byproduct": Reframing Value and Success in Graduate Apprenticeships

Jessica Brennan, New College Lanarkshire

Abstract: Who decides what success looks like?
While Graduate Apprenticeships (GAs) offer a distinct educational model that integrates a degree with workplace practice, their representation signals broader questions about learner voice and the ways that metrics can obscure learner‑defined successes. GAs are framed in policy rhetoric as being mutually beneficial to universities, employers and apprentices, yet persistent challenges around curriculum relevance, employer engagement and learner retention raise questions about the benefits offered to apprentices – a group whose voices remain comparatively underrepresented in the literature.
Through interviews and a qualitative questionnaire, staff and apprentices at a Scottish post-92 university described their experiences of learning and teaching across four GA programmes. Their accounts revealed that many apprentices look beyond the credential itself for value, emphasising how meaningful participation in learning activities contributed to personal and professional growth. Current success measures consider only those who complete a GA programme in its entirety to be "achievers" but these insights challenge this narrow framing of success, reinforcing the need for a more holistic overview that better captures the diverse pathways and personalised goals that characterise work‑based higher education.
This presentation will examine how key elements of programme design and delivery shape the value apprentices derive from their learning, highlighting the importance of negotiated outcomes, relational teaching approaches and alignment across the dual learning environment. In doing so, the presentation contributes to discussions on designing curricula and institutional systems that support learners to succeed in ways that matter to them, bridging the gap between aspiration and achievement.

Keywords: Graduate Apprenticeships; work-based learning; relational pedagogy; educational value; success measures; learner voice

 

Teaching Between Worlds: The Transition Experiences of University Educators in Apprenticeship Programmes

Conor Mellon, Technological University Dublin

Abstract: The expansion of apprenticeship provision within Irish higher education has intensified demand for educators transitioning from industry into academic roles. While such transitions are increasingly common, little empirical work has examined the lived experiences and identity formation of those teaching on apprenticeship programmes. This study explores how industry professionals make sense of their transition into academia and negotiate their emerging professional identities within this distinctive educational context. Adopting a narrative inquiry approach and underpinned by Kelchtermans’ (2009) conceptualisation of professional self‑understanding and Schlossberg’s (2011) transition theory, data were generated through narrative interviews. The findings illuminate a complex and often non‑linear transition characterised by strong vocational commitments, emotionally charged identity work, and tensions between industry credibility and academic recognition. Participants emphasised relational, student‑centred pedagogies and relied heavily on informal networks to navigate limited institutional support. The study contributes empirical insight into apprenticeship education by foregrounding transition as an ongoing process of identity negotiation rather than skills acquisition alone. Implications are discussed for apprenticeship pedagogy, academic development, and institutional support structures for industry‑to‑academia transitions.

Keywords: Industry‑to‑academia transition; Professional identity; Apprenticeship education

 

Room B - 20-minute Presentations

Building a Compassionate Curriculum for Student Wellbeing

Philip Carey, Liverpool John Moores University

Abstract: Today’s students face unprecedented challenges. They navigate rising tuition fees, housing insecurity, mental health pressures, and intense competition in the job market. Systemic inequalities further compound these difficulties, making university life increasingly demanding—despite its promise of opportunity and personal growth.
In this context, growing attention is being paid to the role of the curriculum itself in shaping student wellbeing. This presentation focuses on the concept of the compassionate curriculum—an approach that embeds care, fulfilment, and wellbeing into the very fabric of teaching and learning. It is driven by a desire to support, to reduce stress, and to eliminate unnecessary distress for both students and staff.
The session will share the development of a 'Manifesto for a Compassionate Curriculum', which has been published by RAISE (Researching, Advancing and Inspiring Student Engagement) - UK-based international network committed to enhancing student engagement in higher education. The manifesto emerged from a series of conversations within RAISE’s Special Interest Group that consistently pointed to one conclusion: the student journey improves when wellbeing is explicitly and strategically considered in curriculum design.
This presentation will explore how wellbeing can be embedded in curriculum content, pedagogy, and assessment, and how student support services can complement these efforts. It will also examine the influence of the hidden curriculum - the unspoken norms and expectations of university life - and how these can either support or hinder the development of compassionate learning environments.
Educators, institutional leaders, and policymakers are invited to reflect on how compassion can become a guiding principle in curriculum design, helping to create inclusive, humane, and empowering educational experiences.

Keywords: Compassionate curriculum, wellbeing, mental health, student support

 

Adopting Compassionate Communication in Scotland’s Tertiary Sector

Megan Brown, QAA Scotland, Rachel Horrocks-Birss, QAA Scotland

Abstract: Compassionate communication is an approach adopted by institutions to improve their interactions with students. It involves clear, empathetic, and supportive communication and is aligned with the values of kindness, respect, timeliness, and inclusivity. Undertaking this approach demonstrates a commitment to understanding student needs and ensuring that policies and communications are delivered in a way that is thoughtful and beneficial to all students.
The development of compassionate approaches is a key priority area for the Scottish tertiary sector. Building on the UK's Mental Health Implementation Taskforce’s statement on Compassionate Communication, owned by the Academic Registrars’ Council, QAA Scotland has launched a project exploring the challenges in adopting compassionate approaches and facilitating the sharing of good practice across the Scottish sector. In the context of a student population increasingly impacted by mental health challenges, a continued focus on digital education and what student support looks like in online spaces, and ongoing considerations of the use of AI in communications with students, this topic is timely and relevant to all Scotland’s colleges and universities.
Our project consists of three phases: a review of existing practice, a series of roundtables with representatives from across the Scottish sector, and the development of resources to embed compassionate approaches within institutions. In our presentation, we will discuss themes from the literature and share how the roundtable events allowed the sector to shape the project, ensuring our resources reflect the needs of staff and students. Focussing on institutional-level strategies, our presentation explores the ways in which compassionate approaches can be embedded as a means of supporting an increasingly diverse student body and improving outcomes for all students.

Keywords: Compassion, mental health, student support, inclusion

 

Room C - 20-minute Presentations

The Gap is Not Fixed: Tracking Black Awarding Gap Trajectories Across Transitions to Inform Timely Intervention

Zehui Yang & Benedict Watling, Buckinghamshire New University

Abstract: The Black-White awarding gap is often treated as static and measured at the end of the student lifecycle; this study shows it is dynamic and shaped by key transition points. Using a 2023/24 Nursing cohort at Buckinghamshire New University, a widening participation institution, we track attainment and mark trajectories from Level 4 to Level 6. Logistic regression and linear mixed effects models are used to analyse outcomes, controlling for deprivation, age, gender, and entry qualifications. Patterns observed can be applied to the sector in the importance of student support at transition points.
Findings reveal that the Black-White mark gap widens between Level 4 and Level 5 before partially recovering at Level 6. Trajectory plots show that while all students experience a sharp dip in marks at Level 5, Black students dip more sharply and from a lower baseline. These disparities persist after controlling for all covariates, pointing to structural rather than individual drivers (Hubbard, 2026).
Focus groups with teaching staff suggest that intensive pastoral support introduced at Level 5 and 6 may have contributed to the partial gap recovery observed in the final year. In contrast, the sharp widening at Level 5 coincided with the pandemic-era pressures disproportionately affecting Black students, highlighting the potential cost of delayed intervention.
For the sector, this study offers two insights. First, the Black awarding gap is not fixed: data-informed interventions before Level 5 may buffer the heightened academic demand and move the dial on the Black awarding gap, complementing the sector's commitment to personalised support (TASO, 2024). Second, while COVID-19 provides this study's context, the structural vulnerabilities it exposed, such as financial precarity, disrupted learning, and reduced belonging, persist through the current cost-of-living crisis. For widening participation institutions, student transitions cannot be treated as routine, as they are where equity is won or lost.

Keywords: Awarding gap, attainment trajectories, academic outcomes, Black students, Widening participation

 

Navigating Post-Graduation: The impact of commuting on labour market outcomes and experiences

Rachael King, University of Edinburgh, Abby Cabrelli

Abstract: While recent scholarship has explored how commuter students negotiate their social and academic identities during their studies, there remains a significant research gap regarding how commuting impacts post-graduate life chances and labour market success. At the University of Edinburgh, Scottish-domiciled commuter students comprise approximately 45% of that demographic and are frequently characterised by intersectional disadvantage, being more likely to be mature students, from BAME backgrounds, disabled, or from deprived areas. This project utilises a mixed-methods approach to investigate the post-graduation destinations and experiences of former commuter students. Through secondary analysis of Graduate Outcomes Survey (GOS) data, the study compares the employment outcomes of commuters against non-commuters, controlling for variables such as widening participation (WP) status, age, and ethnicity. This quantitative foundation is complemented by in-depth interviews with alumni to capture qualitative insights into their transition to the labour market, their use of university careers services, and their perceptions of how commuting influenced their professional prospects. Preliminary literature suggests that while commuting can maintain vital local social capital, it often results in depleted informal social networks and reduced access to on-campus support services. This study aims to determine if these factors translate into a ‘class ceiling’ or reduced chances of obtaining highly skilled employment. Ultimately, the findings will inform university policy and Careers Service practice, ensuring that institutional support is effectively tailored to mitigate the long-term inequalities faced by commuter students. By highlighting diverse graduate voices, the project seeks to improve the transition from ancient university settings to the modern global labour market.

Keywords: commuting, outcomes, inequalities