Room A - 20-minute Presentations
Evaluating Scotland’s Tertiary Enhancement Programme
Rachel Horrocks-Birss, QAA Scotland, Megan Brown, QAA Scotland.
Abstract: STEP (Scotland's Tertiary Enhancement Programme) is the national enhancement programme for the Scottish tertiary sector. At the heart of STEP are collaborative enhancement projects with student and staff representation from across all Scotland's tertiary institutions. Under the current topic of Supporting Diverse Learner Journeys, STEP facilitates cross-institutional enhancement work between colleges and universities, involving a wide range of participants and stakeholders, including academics, professional services, student representatives and senior leadership. The vision for STEP is a sector working as a whole to improve and enhance learning, teaching, the student experience, and staff development across tertiary provision.
Our presentation explores the management of STEP, particularly the methods through which we define priorities and measure impact. STEP is sector-owned, with priorities set and monitored by cross-sector governance groups. Using a Theory of Change model, we outline the transformation we expect to see, including the developments we have already observed at this halfway point of the first four-year cycle. As we look toward the reflection year at the conclusion of the cycle, we discuss our upcoming work to involve students and staff in disseminating, embedding, and evaluating the outputs from STEP projects.
Keywords: Quality enhancement, theory of change, collaboration, measuring impact
Understanding and Embedding Belonging in Scotland’s Tertiary Education Sector: Early Findings from a Collaborative Project
Stella Howden, Heriot-Watt University, Patty Watters (Open University of Scotland) and Lisa Nowak (SRUC, Scotland's Rural College)
Abstract: This paper presents early phase-one, insights from a sector-wide enhancement project exploring how student belonging and mattering are understood, developed, and embedded across Scotland’s tertiary education landscape. Delivered through Scotland’s Tertiary Enhancement Programme (STEP), the Appreciating Belonging and Enabling Change project brings together staff and student partners from colleges and universities as part of the project team to develop shared, evidence-informed understandings of effective practice.
The work responds to a changing higher education context in which increasingly diverse student populations arrive at colleges and universities with varied expectations, confidence levels, and support needs (Blake et al, 2022; CDN, 2024) In this environment, fostering belonging is central to enhancing student engagement, persistence, and success (Allen et al, 2024). Furthermore, aligning with sector priorities around inclusive practice, enhancement-led development, and evidence-informed approaches are essential to improving students' experiences and outcomes.
Using an appreciative inquiry approach, the study draws on a curated set of evaluated and sustained case studies of belonging activities/programmes from across Scotland’s tertiary sector. It focuses on identifying what works well by examining the conditions and approaches that enable belonging to be meaningfully developed and sustained over time.
The paper offers practical insights for practitioners and leaders seeking to design, scale, and sustain belonging initiatives. Finally, it highlights the importance of building staff capability in using evidence and evaluation to inform enhancements, contributing to a more consistent and collaborative sector-wide approach.
Keywords: Belonging initiatives, mattering, tertiary education, inclusion, evaluation
Room B - 20-minute Presentations
The Neuroinclusive Classroom
Dr Rebecca J. Sharman, Abertay University
Abstract: There is substantial existing work looking at how the support services can best work with neurodivergent students, but very little that looks at the changes teaching staff can make to their practice. The neuroinclusive classroom project aims to provide guidance to teaching staff to not only improve student experience, academic performance and retention, but also to give staff confidence in their approaches. The project is grounded in universal design for learning and compassionate pedagogy. We have developed a research-based set of materials that can be delivered in a seminar environment or accessed online. The resources start from first principles looking at different neurotypes and their associated challenges (and opportunities), before working through how these might manifest in a teaching environment, and finally offering concrete suggestions for teaching practice. In the development of the guidance it has been important to consider the time pressures that teaching staff work under and ensure that suggestions are realistic and manageable in order that they are seen as achievable aims rather than abstract aspirations. In the latest phase of the project, we have gathered student and staff feedback on the resources which will be used as the basis for further development.
The presentation will give an overview of the project with some examples from the materials and discussion of the feedback and future directions. A particular focus will be given to changing the mindset of teaching staff and their responses to students, as a highly effective method of improving inclusivity and belonging in students without unduly increasing staff workloads.
Keywords: Neurodiversity, ADHD, Autism, Compassionate pedagogy, inclusivity, pedagogy
Listening with Compassion: Using a logic chain and theory of change model to evaluate the use of podcasts to foster compassionate pedagogy within an academic enhancement programme.
Vikki Hill, Queen Margaret University
Abstract: In this presentation, I present an impact-driven process evaluation of a pilot academic enhancement programme - Fostering Belonging and Compassionate Pedagogy (Hill et al, 2020) that aimed to develop compassionate pedagogy (Gilbert, 2017) to reduce ethnicity awarding differentials. This report formed part of the submission for the Office for Students access and participation plan. In this small-scale qualitative study that combines interviews with graphic-elicitation methods. I focus on the experiences of academic and support staff of listening to two podcasts: Belonging in Higher Education (Bunting et al., 2020a) and Belonging in Online Learning Environments (Bunting et al., 2020b) that explore belonging and relationality in higher education (Bunting and Hill, 2021). The evaluation methodology draws from learnings from Thomas (2020) and combines both logic chains and theory of change as programme theory evaluation tools (Rogers et al., 2020) to articulate the relationships between time periods, benefits, outcome and impact.
The research questions aligned to the first six steps of the programme evaluation model and asked how did listening to the podcast contribute to academic staff’s understanding of the relational dimensions of their teaching practice and what (if any) changes did academic staff make to their own teaching practice in relation to compassion. To capture experiences, changes in attitude and behaviour as indicators, I employed visual methods to explore multiple realities and ways of knowing recognising that we communicate differently when using visual materials (Pink, 2013). The evaluation provides insights for future design and iteration of educational development to address inequity and informs recommendations to create compassionate cultures for staff; devise inclusive and affective resources and develop interventions that provide space for both epistemic and practical considerations.
Keywords: Compassionate pedagogy, academic enhancement, logic chain, theory of change, process evaluation, visual methods