Room A - Lightning Talks
Beyond the Numbers: Qualitative Analysis of Academic Integrity Data to Support Student Outcomes
Kerith George-Briant, Abertay University
Abstract: This presentation explores how academic integrity data is being analysed and used in compassionate and constructive ways to enhance student outcomes at Abertay University.
Using the qualitative data which is routinely collected as part of Abertay’s academic misconduct process, the presentation will show how this data has helped inform institutional conversations about curriculum design, induction, AI literacy, and targeted support.
The approach is grounded in the idea that quantitative misconduct data does not reveal the whole story (Driscoll, 2007). While the data may appear to show individual student failure, set in context, qualitative analysis (Lim, 2024) can also reveal that enhancements in transition, assessment design, academic skills development, communication, and student belonging are needed.
By examining variation across levels of study, fee status, reasons for referral and categories of academic misconduct, this presentation will demonstrate how such analysis can support colleagues across academic, professional services, and student support teams in terms of where interventions may be most effective.
By aligning academic integrity data with the broader institutional goals of student success and belonging (Abertay, 2026), this presentation speaks directly to HEIR 2026’s focus on enhancement, compassion, analytics, and data. It offers a practical example of how institutional research can inform action across the university, improve understanding among colleagues, and contribute to improved student outcomes through evidence-informed decision-making.
Keywords: Academic misconduct; Qualitative data; Student outcomes; Compassionate change; Evidence‑informed
Studying Scots contract law online: Belonging and mattering as pillars to engagement and learning
Thorsten Lauterbach, Robert Gordon University
Abstract: The professionally accredited Online LLB at RGU is aimed at learners returning to HE who would otherwise be unable to do so, e.g. due to their location, family/work commitments. Scots contract law is taken by 60-80 mature students and runs over ten teaching weeks, with four substantive 75-minute real-time tutorials and three Moodle discussion forums.
We know that online learning can be a daunting and lonely experience which impacts on engagement and often creates insecurity around social and mental wellbeing and belonging. The focal point of this paper seeks to address the key challenge in building relationships and rapport with online students across very few interactions. In the tutorials we link substantive law with the students’ rich personal and professional experiences, often their non-Scottish, comparative backgrounds as well as current developments to contextualise our mutual learning. The implementation of a responsive curriculum approach opens the door to deeper engagement and reflection on why and how we reach decisions, introducing aspects of deliberative practice into legal education.
In this way the tutorials are central to driving the students’ curiosity, the space and stage for the students to realise how crucial they and their contributions are to our learning journey. Post-Covid pedagogy re-emphasises an inclusive, empathetic approach to help students to develop their confidence to contribute to an environment based on tolerance and mutual trust, particularly in online learning environments. Together, students and teacher create a community of learning which supports individual and collective mental and social wellbeing: all participants develop a sense of belonging and that their contributions matter during a short semester where time is at a premium.
Key transferable insights to support student belonging and mattering include the worthwhile investment of time to get to know the student cohort as the very foundation to build strong relationships (learner-learner-teacher) and develop a bond of mutual trust, respect, the development of learners’ confidence by drawing on their prior experiences as a significant resource, real-time learning events being dialogic and social spaces, and the significant role of e-learning technology as “co-enabler”, particularly in online/blended learning.
Keywords: Belonging and mattering; health and well-being; learning community; empathy; responsive curriculum
Coaching for Success
Stephen Morrison, Abertay University, Agnes Branny
Abstract: A significant number of graduates experience barriers to employment and will not find employ-ment without intervention and bespoke support. Graduates with significant barriers include those with lifestyle constraints; carers, or personal barriers such as autism, mental health conditions or other health impairments. These are the most complex students with significant fac-tors and barriers in their lives to overcome.
Disabled students make up nearly 20% of the undergraduate population and numerous disabled graduates experience a full-time employment gap of 5% or more across all qualification levels (The Shaw Trust, 2012). Destination statistics and outcomes for students with disabilities are low in comparison to peer groups (see Appendix 1).
At Abertay in the academic year 2023-2024, 24% of our student demographic disclosed or de-clared a disability, health issue, learning difficulty or impairment. A total of 1004 students. Many students choose not to disclose so the actual numbers will be higher.
Furthermore, Dundee and Tayside Dundee and Tayside have less opportunities economically (comparatively) for graduates1. Dundee City’s employment rate was lower than across Scotland in the year ending December 2023. https://www.ons.gov.uk/visualisations/labourmarketlocal/S12000042/ Last updated 14 May 2024
Graduates with disabilities have in some cases limited geographic mobility, lack of networks, lack of advocacy and family support (financial and otherwise) to move to other areas to secure graduate opportunities. In addition, some graduates with disabilities must overcome social stigma and workplace discrimination.
The ability to overcome significant barriers is key to graduates with disabilities. Success for this graduate cohort requires bespoke time devoted to coaching and by working with local employ-ers we will enhance the employment opportunities.
By creating a model for inclusive recruitment, we will support graduates with barriers to employment and work with local employers to enhance inclusive employment practises in Tayside through dedicated 1-1 coaching approaches.
Keywords: Focused Coaching; Graduates; Addressing Personal barriers; Graduates Outcomes
Widening Access at Scale: Supporting Diverse Student Transitions at The Open University in Scotland
Lindsay Wilson, The Open University in Scotland, David Johnstone, Dana Mciver and Patty Watters all the Open University in Scotland
Abstract: The Open University in Scotland (OUiS) supports more than 15,000 students whose routes into higher education often differ significantly from those assumed by traditional university models. Many balance study alongside employment, caring responsibilities, health conditions and financial pressures, while others are entering higher education for the first time. For these learners, the period immediately before study begins can be critical in shaping confidence, engagement and expectations of success.
This lightning talk proposes that the student welcome experience should be viewed as a strategic intervention rather than a series of administrative or induction activities. Drawing on enhancement work at OUiS, it explores how intentionally designed welcome events can support students to develop a sense of belonging, build confidence in their capabilities and increase their readiness to study before formal learning starts.
The presentation will outline the principles underpinning OUiS's approach to welcome and transition, including coordinated early interventions that connect students with peers, academic staff, specialist support services and opportunities to develop confidence and readiness before study begins. It will share evidence demonstrating that participation in welcome activities was associated with an average 27% increase in students' reported sense of belonging and preparedness for study.
The presentation concludes by posing a wider sector question: if belonging and readiness are among the strongest foundations for student success, are universities paying enough strategic attention to what happens before learning truly begins?
Keywords: Widening access, part time learners, belonging and preparedness
Room B - Lightning Talks
Is the ROI for undergraduate study diminishing? Evidence from the metrics that drive the Guardian University Guide
Matt Hiely-Rayner, Intelligent Metrix Ltd / the University of Sussex
Abstract: The parlous state of the UK higher education sector is never far from the headlines, whether it be institutions trimming their portfolios of courses that make insufficient financial contribution, graduates encountering the reality of lifelong loan repayments, or freshly qualified students finding that the opportunities they expected to find after graduation are fewer and less attractive than they might have imagined.
The undertone in all these stories is a recurring question: is higher education still worth it? Is the ‘return’ from the entire experience valuable enough to justify the investment: the immediate costs, followed by the debt? Putting aside variability in the terms and conditions of repayments, while acknowledging that there is variability in the understanding of how satisfying these terms feels for a generation progressing through their careers, this talk examines output measures to seek any evidence of trends in perception of value. Drawing upon multiple years of undergraduate data that has fed into the Guardian University Guide, including the latest data on graduate perceptions of their original study choices, are there indications that the value of the UK HE experience is in decline?
Keywords: League tables, rankings, outcomes, satisfaction, continuation, graduate outcomes
SEER Illuminating the Hidden Curriculum Research Project: An initial Discussion
Charlotte Boulton, Applied Inspiration, Ashley Reilly-Thornton, Applied Inspiration
Abstract: Our talk seeks to present the concept and pilot data from the SEER Illuminating the Hidden Curriculum research project, which aims to examine the impact of the hidden curriculum on student transition and success.
We define the hidden curriculum as unwritten assumptions, norms, and expectations that can profoundly influence academic success, belonging and engagement, which remain unequal across student groups.
We seek to understand student experiences of the hidden curriculum at small and specialist higher education providers in England – an institutional and educational context that is largely omitted from research on student transitions.
Our research approach combines working with students as co-researchers and deploying participatory research methods, such as listening rooms, to engage our research participants. The partnership approach involves setting up a panel of student contributors and co-researchers that will work to uncover the components of the hidden curriculum and links to unequal outcomes and experiences for students from underrepresented backgrounds.
Our mixed-method research design involves:
- Co-designing tools for collecting qualitative data on the hidden curriculum; the student panel will consider these data to identify hidden curriculum themes.
- Using quantitative and qualitative data to determine the baselines of impact of the hidden curriculum on academic success, belonging, and engagement across critical points in the student journey, different provider contexts, and for different underrepresented backgrounds.
- Developing evidence-based interventions at the participant providers that align with their access and participation agendas and aim to support student transitioning through the critical points by removing barriers related to the hidden curriculum.
- Evaluating the impact of the interventions on belonging, engagement, and success outcomes like retention, progression, and attainment.
Through our talk, we hope to contribute to conversations around compassionate, student-partnered approaches to understanding the transition experience of students from diverse and complex backgrounds.
Keywords: Hidden curriculum; Student partnership & co-creation; Participatory research methods; Transitioning in higher education; Access and participation
Enhancing Student Outcomes in Undergraduate Cybersecurity Education Through Practical Curriculum Interventions and Learning Analytics
Mohamed Naisar Fathima, Mohamed Naisar Fathima
Abstract: The increasing demand for industry-ready cybersecurity graduates has highlighted the need for higher education institutions to move beyond traditional theory-based teaching approaches and adopt evidence-informed curriculum enhancement strategies. Undergraduate cybersecurity education presents some unique pedagogical challenges, as students are expected to develop both conceptual knowledge as well as practical technical competencies in areas such as network security, ethical hacking, digital forensics, and secure systems designs. This study examines the impact of practical curriculum interventions combined with learning analytics on the student engagement and academic outcomes within undergraduate cybersecurity modules at a higher education institution. The intervention involved redesigning selected modules to incorporate enhanced practical laboratory sessions, applied assessment components, scenario-based learning activities, and more frequent formative feedback opportunities. These changes were intended to improve student engagement, strengthen skill acquisition, and better align learning experiences with industry expectations. A mixed-methods approach was adopted, using institutional and module-level data including student grades, attendance records, learning management system engagement metrics, and student feedback data. Comparative analysis was conducted across cohorts before and after curriculum implementation to identify changes in progression, attainment, and engagement patterns. Preliminary findings indicate improvements in student participation, assessment performance, and practical competency development following the intervention. Learning analytics also enabled earlier identification of at-risk students, supporting more timely and targeted academic interventions. The findings contribute to current discussions on curriculum enhancement, analytics-informed teaching practice, and compassionate institutional approaches to student success. By integrating practical curriculum design with data-informed decision-making, this study demonstrates how discipline-specific enhancements can support diverse learner needs while improving academic outcomes in technical higher education environments. The paper offers practical recommendations for computing, computer security and cybersecurity educators seeking to design more engaging, industry-relevant, and student-centered learning environments.
Keywords: Cybersecurity Education, Curriculum Enhancement, Learning Analytics, Student Outcomes, Higher Education
Create, Curate, Critique: A Community Approach to Enhanced Wellbeing.
Imogen Rixon-Gibb, Abertay University, Lauren Hempseed; Laura Wakeford; Marcia Stoll and Lynn Wright (all Abertay University)
Abstract: As student mental health continues to decline (Emmerton et al., 2024), universities are struggling to meet increased demands on counselling and support services (Lipson et al., 2019). This is concerning as mental health is linked to academic attainment (Frazier et al., 2018) and retention (Leow et al., 2024). To address this gap, we propose a more proactive approach to building community and resilience within our university population.
Research demonstrates that creative activities improve wellbeing and reduce anxiety, benefitting individuals and groups alike (Shukla et al., 2022). An array of activities (e.g., modelling with clay, painting and sewing) have been shown to contribute to enhanced wellbeing. Additionally, mindful arts-based activities, such as colouring, are reported to reduce stress and boost resilience.
This project involves the creation, implementation and evaluation of a series of creative workshops for students and staff. These consist of short, creative activities aimed to enhance student and staff wellbeing and strengthen a sense of community. Quantitative (e.g., questionnaires) and Qualitative (e.g., interviews) evaluations of workshops/activities will be reported. These findings will guide the refinement/enhancement of future wellbeing toolkits and workshops. Findings will be discussed in the context of benefits and barriers to engagement.
Keywords: Community; Creative Workshops; Wellbeing; Engagement.